We look to have our work critiqued for different reasons.
Some photographers look for validation, and some look to improve their work.
A critique based on improving our work is the best kind of critique.
But be careful because some comments are useless to
us.
What Is a Photography Critique?
At its
base, a photography critique is a deconstruction of a photograph.
We can break this down into two different types of critique.
The first type of critique is a factual critique. The second type of critique is an opinionated
critique.
Factual Photography Critiques
A
factual photography critique is nothing more than a description of the elements of composition.
A factual critique is simply an objective deconstruction of the photograph, describing the compositional elements that constitute
it.
For example, the apparent visual effects of our choices for aperture, shutter speed, ISO, and other camera options.
An Opinionated Critique
An opinionated photography critique builds upon the factual photography critique by adding an opinion.
We could do this in the form of a self-critique or ask someone to critique our work.
And by the way, a self-critique should occur immediately after creating a photograph.
There Are Helpful Critiques, and There Are Unhelpful Critiques
I think self-critiques are ALWAYS helpful critiques because self-critiques allow us to evaluate our work and provide guidance on how we could improve our photography.
Additionally, I believe that opinionated critiques are helpful ONLY IF the one giving the analysis involves the one asking for the critique.
Specifically, the one giving the analysis/critique should ask the one requesting the critique what their intent of communication was when creating the photograph, and what precisely does not
communicate that intent.
A Word About Self-Critiques
I can't say enough about the importance of self-critique.
Learning this skill is transformative for our process and outcomes.
The connection is that when we deconstruct our picture into its compositional elements, we see where we visually fell short in terms of our communication intent.
This process helps us see our
strengths AND weaknesses in terms of our understanding of the relationship between our camera operation, composition, and the light we photograph
And knowing what we don't know is as important as knowing what we do know.
The Photography Basics/Introduction To Photography class is scheduled and’ll help you learn what you don’t know and so will a series of private lessons.
However you choose to study and practice with me, I’ll help you become the best photographer you can be.
And if you’re not sure which class fits your needs, just ask—I’m always happy to help.
There’s more ways to learn photography with me listed below.